Just see the world with the holy heart

Should NBC have shown video of Nodar Kumaritashvili's death?

When NBC kicked off its coverage of the 2010 Winter Olympics on Friday night, it was with a much different introduction than originally planned. The broadcast started at 7:30 p.m. ET with a somber intro from Bob Costas and Matt Lauer that detailed the death of Georgian luger Nodar Kumaritashvil earlier in the day. It was a respectful and necessary decision, but far from the triumphant opening sequence that was doubtlessly in the can.

After a brief description of the tragedy from Costas and Lauer, the pair sent it to NBC News anchor Brian Williams, who delivered a lengthy report on the death. At the start of the piece, Williams warned viewers that "the pictures are very tough for some people to watch," but he spoke for just a few more seconds before video of Kumaritashvili's final run began. So when the video opened with a shot of the 21-year-old waiting in the gate before his training run, it was a bit jarring. It became more so when the video jumped ahead to the horrific crash, which was shown in slow motion. Seconds later, a longer, slower shot was shown. A still photo of Kumaritashvili receiving CPR was also broadcast. During the eight-minute report that opened the show, NBC showed the crash three times, the final two of which lingered on shots of the Georgian's body.

Other than the initial airing of the video, everything else seemed gratuitous. Showing Kumaritashvili in the gate 48 seconds before his death was eerie, and the photo of him getting attended to by first responders was the definition of macabre. He was already dead. What is the news value in showing him futilely receiving CPR?

Though it's been written that airing the clip was a sensationalistic ratings grab, it was a perfectly acceptable decision (even if it's at 7:30 p.m. ET in a program geared toward family viewership). Still, it's safe to say that a vast majority of the 38 million Americans who were watching the Opening Ceremony hadn't yet seen the gruesome clip of Kumaritashvili flying off the course and crashing into a metal pole. Was a brief warning that suggested only "some people" would find it tough to see enough?

Before we vilify NBC, let's recognize that they were in a difficult spot. If they didn't show the video, people would be complaining that the network was protecting its asset (the Olympics) and not providing detailed coverage of an important story. That wouldn't be gratuitous, it would be bad journalism. Overall, the network handled a bad situation in a professional way.

NBC was right to cover the story, and showing the video was a necessary news decision. The network, which usually holds a tight grip on Olympic footage, even released the tape to other news organizations because "this was a significant news event." However, showing it three times at the beginning of coverage without an adequate warning and then airing a picture of a lifeless body getting medical attention was irresponsible.



  1. If Kumaritashvil were an American, do you think NBC would have shown the footage? Do you think his hypothetical American family would have said nothing to NBC?


    They should never have shown it.

  2. This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I enjoy seeing websites that understand the value of providing a prime resource for free. I truly loved reading your post. Thanks!


Hello (^-^)v

Search Here

Custom Search


accounting airline airplane airways alchemy alien android animal artist automotive baby beatle beauty betelguese blackjack business cancer car car insurance cartoon casino castle caterpillar celebrity cellophane celluloid century change cheap chess child china christmas city claim clinton coffee come from comment computer console cook cookies coral cosplay county credit cards cricket culture dating dead definition design diet disaster divers dofollow domain drive drug dwarf ear earthquake easy education effect egyptian elephants exchange link family fancy-free farming fashion fat finance fingerprint first installed first killed first plastic fish fitness flare flight flower follow your comment food footloose forex free gadget gambling games geology ghost gold goldfish golf Google gossip goverment great wall grow gypsies hair harvard hawaii head header health Healthy Life hear heavy metal herbal herbs himalaya historic sites historical history history of naruto hocus pocus hollywood hollywood sign home honeybee hormon hotels in hollywood how how long human body idea insect Inspire insurance introduced invented invest island japan japannesse jet jewelry job junk ken uston kids kitten knowledge konoha ninjas law Lawyer learn lego liberty bell lion loan logo love lyrics magician magnetic mail mammoth many market meal medical memoriam metal gallium metallica mining miracle mistery money mortgage mosquito mountain move murderer music Music Artist myth naruto history nature navigation neuron star new year news nike nobel prize not a sloution notification obama old olympic online online business orchid ornament other paid to click painite. gem painting party patent pendet dance people pet piranha pizza planet plant poem poker prediction presentation queen railway rare reborn recycle religion retouch river rockwalk romantic salmon scotch sea seat seating sell SEO Space sport star strange moment street study success people sunrise swoosh symbol tape tari pendet tax tea keep technology term tickets tips toothpick tour de france tourism tourist toy travel traveling children trend tsunami tusk twins usa uzumaki naruto vacation vegetable venus video visit Indonesia war water west what are wild wine wolly woman word work wright ಬ್ಲೂ ಚಿಪ್

Popular Posts

Copyright © Vision in memorial. All rights reserved. Template by CB